Gryphons, dragons, and phoenixes.
Pegicorn thats a unicorn and pegasus all as one. :)
Elves or dwarves
Fairies! I love fairies.
vampires, fairies, elves, dragons, shape-shifter, magical sea creatures!
Buckbeak! From Harry Potter!
mythical puppies if there is such i thing idk :)
Hybrid Vampire/Werewolf because I am one and it would be nice to find others of my kind. So I don't feel as alone. :)
Fey and/or Elves (Germanic ones, not the little Christmassy ones). I like Land Spirits as well, but that is a very large span of creatures!